Last updated: October 20, 2026
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research and rate.
The short version
The date on almost every package in your kitchen is not required by federal law, was chosen by the manufacturer, and is not a safety date.
Except for infant formula, product dating is not required by federal regulations. The dates that appear are voluntary, they describe peak quality rather than safety, and the phrase beside them — sell-by, use-by, best if used by, freeze-by — means four different things that most people read as one.
The consequence is an enormous amount of food thrown away while still perfectly good, which is why the agency responsible has been pushing manufacturers toward a single clearer phrase.
What the confusion costs
What the law actually requires
Start with the sentence that reframes the whole subject.
Except for infant formula, product dating is not required by federal regulations. For meat, poultry and egg products, dates may be applied voluntarily, provided they are truthful, not misleading and compliant with the applicable regulations.
Where a date is applied, the formatting rules are specific:
- The calendar date must express both the month and the day of the month.
- For shelf-stable and frozen products, the year must also appear.
- Immediately adjacent to the date there must be a phrase explaining what it means, such as “Best if Used By”.
That third requirement is the useful one. A bare date with no explanatory phrase is not doing what the rules contemplate, and the phrase is what tells you which of four quite different meanings applies.
There is a second kind of dating that most shoppers never decode. “Open dating” is the calendar date applied by a manufacturer or retailer, telling consumers how long the product will be at its best quality and helping the store manage display time. “Closed dating” is a code — letters and numbers — applied by manufacturers to identify the date and time of production. The code on a can is closed dating, which is why it looks like nothing you can read.
The four phrases, and what each one means
| Phrase | What it means | Is it a safety date? |
| “Best if Used By” | The product will be of best quality if used by this date. The phrase FSIS recommends | No |
| “Sell-By” | Tells the store how long to display the product for inventory management | No |
| “Use-By” | The last date recommended for use at peak quality | No — except on infant formula |
| “Freeze-By” | When a product should be frozen to maintain peak quality | No, and not a purchase date either |
Three observations follow, and each corrects a common reading.
“Sell-By” is not addressed to you at all. It is a message from the manufacturer to the retailer about shelf rotation. A shopper treating it as a deadline is reading someone else’s mail.
“Use-By” sounds like the strictest phrase and generally is not. On ordinary food it marks peak quality, not safety. The single exception is the one this page keeps returning to.
“Best if Used By” is the recommended phrasing precisely because it is the clearest. Research cited by the agency shows this wording conveys what is actually meant — quality, not safety — better than the alternatives.
The infant formula exception
One food in the American grocery store carries a legally required date, and the reason is worth understanding because it explains what a real date guarantee looks like.
Federal regulations require a “Use-By” date on infant formula. Using the formula by that date ensures it contains each nutrient in the quantity listed on the label, and that the product maintains an acceptable quality to pass through an ordinary bottle nipple.
That second clause is a lovely piece of specificity — the regulation is concerned not only with nutrient degradation but with whether the prepared formula will physically feed.
The date is selected by the manufacturer, packer or distributor based on product analysis throughout shelf life, tests or other information, and on the handling, storage, preparation and use conditions printed on the label. Formula should not be bought or used after its Use-By date.
This connects directly to the testing regime we describe in our infant formula explainer: every batch must be tested at production and again at the end of shelf life. The Use-By date is the boundary of that tested guarantee — which is exactly why it is the one date in the store that means what people think all dates mean.
So how do you actually know if food is still good?
If the date is not a safety indicator, something has to be, and the agency is direct about what.
With the exception of infant formula, a product whose date passes during home storage should still be safe and wholesome if handled properly, until the time spoilage is evident.
Spoilage announces itself. Spoiled foods develop an off odor, flavor or texture from naturally occurring spoilage bacteria, and food showing those characteristics should not be eaten.
The distinction underneath this is worth carrying:
- Spoilage bacteria cause food to deteriorate and lose wholesomeness, producing off tastes and bad odors. They are why food goes obviously bad.
- Pathogenic bacteria cause foodborne illness, and they do not reliably announce themselves through smell, taste or appearance.
That is the genuinely important caveat on this whole page. “Trust your senses rather than the date” is good guidance for quality and for spoilage. It is not a method for detecting pathogens, which is why handling, temperature and cooking matter independently of any date. Your nose tells you whether food has gone off; it does not tell you whether it is contaminated.
One specific myth the agency addresses directly: a change in the color of meat or poultry is not an indicator of spoilage. Beef darkening in the package is a normal chemical reaction with oxygen, and discarding it on that basis is exactly the avoidable waste the 30 percent figure describes.
Why manufacturers pick the dates they pick
Since the dates are voluntary and self-selected, it is fair to ask what goes into them.
The agency describes the factors: the length of time and temperature at which a food is held during distribution and offered for sale, the characteristics of the food itself, and the type of packaging. A sausage formulated with ingredients that preserve quality, or fresh beef in modified atmosphere packaging, will hold quality longer and carry a longer date.
There is an incentive structure here worth naming plainly. A manufacturer setting a conservative date protects itself against a customer eating a stale product and blaming the brand. A shorter date also means faster turnover. Neither motive is sinister, and neither is a food safety calculation.
So the date encodes the manufacturer’s judgment about when its product stops showing well, under assumptions about distribution and storage that may or may not match your kitchen. A product kept consistently colder than assumed will outlast its date; one left in a hot car will not reach it.
Where the date is worth taking seriously
Nothing on this page is an argument for ignoring dates, and there are categories where they carry more weight.
- Infant formula, absolutely, for the reasons above.
- Ready-to-eat refrigerated foods such as deli items, where the risk profile differs from a shelf-stable product and where a use-by date reflects a shorter safe window.
- Products where a nutrient claim is the point. If you are buying something for a specific vitamin content, degradation over time is real even when palatability is not affected.
- Anything whose packaging is compromised — a swollen can, a broken seal, a leaking pouch. That is not a date question at all, and it overrides any date.
- Home-canned goods, which sit outside the commercial system entirely and follow their own guidance.
The rule of thumb that survives all of this: the date is a quality estimate from someone who has not seen your refrigerator, the package condition is a safety signal, and evident spoilage overrides both.
Storage is what actually determines shelf life
If the date assumes conditions, then controlling those conditions is the lever you actually hold.
Temperature does most of the work. Spoilage bacteria multiply faster in warmth, and food spoilage can occur much faster if food is not stored or handled properly. The gap between a refrigerator at the right temperature and one a few degrees warmer is measured in days of shelf life across everything inside it.
Practical points that extend real shelf life:
- Keep the refrigerator cold and check it, rather than assuming the dial is accurate.
- Freeze before the date, not after. Freezing pauses quality where it is; it does not restore what has been lost.
- Decant opened products into sealed containers. Once a package is opened, the date on it describes the unopened product and no longer applies. Our glass food storage guide covers the containers that hold a seal properly.
- Store by zone. The door is the warmest part of a refrigerator and the worst place for milk or eggs, whatever the molded shelves suggest.
- Rotate deliberately, putting new purchases behind old ones, which is the single habit that converts a date into something you act on rather than discover.
Our explainer on storing organic produce covers the fresh side of this, where dates are largely absent and handling is everything.
Freezing, and what it actually does
Freezing is the most misunderstood tool in this whole subject, and getting it right converts dates from a deadline into a decision.
Freezing pauses quality; it does not restore it. Food frozen three days before its date resumes from that point when thawed. Food frozen after it has already declined stays declined. This is why “freeze it before the date, not after” is the single most useful habit on this page.
Properly frozen food stays safe indefinitely. What degrades over months is quality rather than safety — texture, moisture, flavor — through freezer burn and the slow oxidation of fats. A date on a frozen product is describing that quality decline, not a point at which the food becomes hazardous.
Practical points that make the difference:
- Freeze in portions you will actually use. Repeated partial thawing is the fastest route to poor quality, and refreezing thawed food costs texture each time.
- Exclude air. Freezer burn is dehydration at the surface, so the packaging does more for quality than the freezer temperature does.
- Label with the date frozen, since the original package date stops being the relevant number the moment it goes in.
- Thaw in the refrigerator rather than on a counter, which keeps the food out of the temperature range where bacteria multiply fastest.
- Some things freeze badly — high-water vegetables become limp, emulsions can split, and fried textures do not survive — and that is a quality outcome rather than a safety one.
The category where freezing pays off most is baked goods, which stale rapidly at room temperature through a process that freezing arrests almost entirely. Bread frozen on the day of purchase and toasted from frozen is dramatically better than bread four days old on the counter, as our organic bread guide notes.
Dates on the other products in the same cupboard
Because the kitchen holds more than food, it is worth knowing that the rules differ sharply a shelf away.
Drug products are the opposite of food. To assure that a drug product meets applicable standards of identity, strength, quality and purity at the time of use, it must bear an expiration date determined by appropriate stability testing. That is a requirement backed by data, not a manufacturer’s estimate of when a product stops showing well.
There is a long-standing wrinkle worth knowing. Enforcement of that requirement has been suspended for human over-the-counter products whose labeling contains no dosage limitations and where stability data support a shelf life of at least three years — an exemption pending since a proposal published in 1978. So some OTC products legitimately carry no expiration date at all, and that absence reflects a specific regulatory history rather than an oversight.
Where this touches products we cover elsewhere:
- Sunscreen is an OTC drug, and its date matters because the actives degrade — the point our sunscreen labels explainer makes about why an old bottle is not simply weaker but unreliable.
- Fluoride toothpaste and antiperspirant are also OTC drugs, for the reasons set out in our toothpaste and antiperspirant explainers.
- Cosmetics generally carry no required expiration date in the US, though many use a period-after-opening symbol — an open jar marked 6M or 12M — which is a manufacturer convention rather than a federal requirement.
- Dietary supplements sit closer to food than to drugs here, which is consistent with the broader picture our third-party testing explainer describes.
The pattern holds across the whole house. Where a product’s performance is the regulated claim, the date is backed by stability testing. Where the claim is quality or preference, the date is the manufacturer’s judgment. Knowing which cupboard you are standing in tells you how much the number is worth.
The foods that effectively do not expire
A short section, because these are where date-driven waste is least justified.
Honey is the standard example, its water activity and acidity making it inhospitable to the microorganisms that spoil food. Crystallization is not spoilage — our organic honey guide covers what actually distinguishes one jar from another.
Salt and sugar in dry form, which have no water for microbes to use. Caking is a texture problem.
White rice, dried beans and pasta, stored dry and sealed, remain safe far beyond any printed date, with texture and cooking time drifting slowly.
Distilled spirits and white vinegar, which are self-preserving.
Properly canned goods with intact seals, where the limiting factor is gradual quality change rather than safety. Our organic canned tomatoes guide notes where can linings and acidity interact, which is a separate question from dating.
The category to treat differently is fats and oils, which do genuinely degrade. Rancidity is a real chemical change with an unmistakable smell, and it is the clearest case where the date is tracking something that matters.
That last point extends further than the oil bottle, and it is the most useful refinement on this page. Anything with meaningful fat content is on a rancidity clock, whether or not it looks like a fat: nuts and nut butters, whole grain flours carrying the oil-rich germ, seeds, oat products, granola and crackers made with real fat rather than shortening.
Two consequences follow:
- Whole grain products have shorter real shelf lives than refined ones, because refining removes the germ and with it the oil that goes rancid. A whole wheat flour and a white flour with identical printed dates are not equivalent, and the refrigerator or freezer is the correct home for the former.
- Rancidity is detectable and worth learning. The smell is sharp, faintly like old paint or crayons, and once recognized it is unmistakable. It is not dangerous in the way pathogens are, but it makes food unpleasant and it is the one quality failure your nose reliably catches early.
This is why our guides to organic oatmeal and organic crackers pay attention to packaging and pack size: a large economy bag of a fat-containing product is a worse deal than the unit price suggests if half of it turns before you reach it. Buying smaller and more often beats buying large and discarding, which is the same conclusion the 30 percent waste figure points toward from the other direction.
Reading a date in ten seconds
- Find the phrase, not just the date. It is required to be immediately adjacent, and it tells you which of the four meanings applies.
- If it says Sell-By, it is not addressed to you.
- If it says Use-By on infant formula, treat it as binding. On anything else, it is a quality date.
- Check that month and day are present, plus the year on shelf-stable and frozen items.
- Look at the package before the date — seals, swelling, leaks. That is the safety signal.
- Then use your senses, remembering they detect spoilage rather than pathogens.
Step five outranks the rest. A compromised package makes the date irrelevant, and an intact package with a passed date is usually fine.
What a good listing states
Applying the standard we use across every guide, here is what separates an informative listing from a decorative one.
- The shelf life from receipt, rather than only a date the buyer cannot see before purchase.
- Which phrase is used, since sell-by and best-if-used-by imply different remaining windows.
- Storage instructions specific enough to act on — a temperature, not “store in a cool dry place”.
- Post-opening guidance, since the printed date stops applying once a seal is broken.
- Packaging type, which determines how much of the stated shelf life survives real conditions.
In our reading of this category, shelf life from receipt is the most requested and least stated piece of information in online grocery listings — a buyer ordering a case of something has no way to know whether it arrives with eleven months or three weeks remaining.
What the category gets right, and what it does not
The honest assessment is mixed, and it is worth separating the two halves.
What works: requiring an explanatory phrase adjacent to the date is a genuinely good rule, because it makes a bare number interpretable. Requiring the year on shelf-stable and frozen goods closes an obvious gap. And the infant formula requirement is precisely targeted at the one product where the date is a real guarantee.
What does not work: four permitted phrasings for a voluntary date produces exactly the confusion the 30 percent waste figure describes. The agency’s response has been to recommend a single phrase rather than require one, which is a nudge rather than a fix.
So the strategy for dates inverts the habit most households have. Read the phrase rather than the number, treat the package condition as the safety signal, and remember that with one exception the date on the box is a manufacturer’s opinion about quality — not a deadline, and not a law.
Common questions about food date labels
Are food dates required by law?
Except for infant formula, product dating is not required by federal regulations. Where dates are applied voluntarily they must be truthful, not misleading, and accompanied by a phrase explaining what the date means.
Is a “Use-By” date a safety date?
Not on ordinary food, where it marks the last date recommended for use at peak quality. The exception is infant formula, where the Use-By date is required and should be observed.
What does “Sell-By” mean?
It tells the store how long to display the product for sale, for inventory management. It is not a safety date and it is not addressed to the shopper.
Which date phrase does USDA recommend?
FSIS recommends “Best if Used By”, because research shows that wording conveys to consumers that the product will be of best quality if used by the date shown, rather than implying a safety deadline.
Is food safe to eat after the date passes?
With the exception of infant formula, a product whose date passes during home storage should still be safe and wholesome if handled properly, until spoilage is evident through off odor, flavor or texture.
Can I tell by smell whether food is safe?
Smell detects spoilage bacteria, which cause off odors and deterioration. Pathogenic bacteria, which cause foodborne illness, do not reliably announce themselves, so proper handling and cooking matter independently of how food smells.
Does meat turning brown mean it has spoiled?
No. A change in the color of meat or poultry is not an indicator of spoilage. Discarding meat for that reason is a common source of avoidable waste.
Why does infant formula have a required date?
Because using it by that date ensures it contains each nutrient in the quantity listed on the label, and that it maintains acceptable quality to pass through an ordinary bottle nipple. The date is set from product analysis across shelf life.
What is the code stamped on a can?
That is closed dating, a code of letters and numbers applied by the manufacturer to identify the date and time of production. It is used for tracking rather than for consumer guidance.
Does the date still apply after I open the package?
No. The printed date describes the unopened product under the assumed storage conditions. Once a seal is broken, post-opening storage guidance applies instead.
Sources
- Organic Food hub
- Best Organic Canned Tomatoes
- Best Organic Honey
- Best Glass Food Storage Containers
- How to store organic produce
- Infant formula labels explained
- Organic Product Database — compare brands across every guide
Organic Connection is reader supported. We read every product listing in full, check the claims in it, and say plainly when a claim cannot be verified. How we research and rate.
